Imagine a world where Broadway’s brightest stars collide with your favorite TV show—sounds like a dream, right? Well, Carrie Preston is making it her mission to turn this fantasy into reality. The actress, known for her role in Elsbeth, is playfully nudging her new co-star Lindsay Mendez to recruit her Merrily We Roll Along buddies, Daniel Radcliffe and Jonathan Groff, for guest spots on the series. But here’s where it gets exciting: Preston isn’t just joking—she’s dead serious about bringing these theater icons to the small screen. And this is the part most people miss: with showrunner Jon Tolins known for writing roles specifically for actors, it’s not just a pipe dream—it’s a logistical puzzle waiting to be solved.
In a recent chat with Decider, Preston spilled the beans on her grand plan. ‘Hey guys, I’m having a good time on this show,’ she imagines Mendez telling Groff and Radcliffe. ‘We would love that,’ Preston adds, though she’s quick to acknowledge the scheduling hurdles. ‘Jonathan Groff is very busy with his show, and Daniel Radcliffe is pretty busy himself. But of course, I would love that.’ Is this a long shot? Absolutely. But is it worth the effort? Undoubtedly.
Preston’s enthusiasm for Elsbeth is infectious, especially as she dives into the show’s third season. With 20 new episodes on the horizon, the series is already buzzing with big names like Stephen Colbert, Julia Fox, and David Cross. But it’s the potential addition of Radcliffe and Groff that has fans—and Preston—on the edge of their seats. ‘You’ve got to find the holes in their schedules and make it all line up,’ she explains. But here’s the controversial part: should TV shows prioritize fan fantasies over practical casting decisions? Or is this exactly the kind of bold move that keeps audiences hooked?
Speaking of bold moves, Colbert’s recent guest appearance is a masterclass in multitasking. Just days after learning The Late Show was ending, he committed to Elsbeth, showcasing his versatility as an actor, improviser, and talk show host. ‘He made it happen and honored his commitment,’ Preston notes, praising his professionalism. But let’s ask the real question: Are we underestimating Colbert’s acting range? Could this be the start of a new chapter in his career?
On set, Colbert reunited with Amy Sedaris and Andy Richter, creating a comedic trifecta that was both disciplined and delightfully chaotic. ‘They take everything they do seriously,’ Preston says, ‘but they’re also incredibly funny.’ And this is the part most people miss: behind the laughter, there’s a deep respect for the craft that elevates every scene.
Preston’s love for Elsbeth shines through in her attention to detail, especially when it comes to Easter eggs for fans. During a key monologue, she even incorporated a gesture from Merrily We Roll Along, thanks to Mendez’s input. ‘We love to do things like that, to add in little textures, little layers for the fans,’ she explains. But here’s the controversial part: Are these insider references inclusive, or do they alienate casual viewers? Is it possible to strike a balance?
As we wrap up, Preston leaves us with a thought-provoking question: What would her character, Elsbeth, be binge-watching? ‘Probably Only Murders in the Building,’ she muses. ‘She wants to smile and laugh.’ But let’s take it a step further: What does this say about Elsbeth’s personality? Is she more than just a detective—is she a fan of humor and heart?
Elsbeth Season 3 is now streaming on Paramount+, with new episodes airing Thursdays on CBS. Whether you’re a theater buff, a comedy lover, or just a fan of great storytelling, this season promises something for everyone. But here’s the real question: Will Radcliffe and Groff make an appearance? Only time will tell. What do you think—should Preston keep pushing for their guest spots, or is it too much of a stretch? Let us know in the comments!
